[SOLVED] Why container memory usage is doubled in cAdvisor metrics? - kubernetes

Understanding the Doubling of Container Memory Usage in cAdvisor Metrics - Kubernetes

In Kubernetes, it is very important for us to monitor container memory usage. This helps us keep our applications running well and manage resources. But many users see that the memory usage reported in cAdvisor seems to be doubled. This can cause confusion and problems in managing resources.

In this article, we will look into why memory usage is doubled in cAdvisor metrics. We will also give practical solutions to fix this problem. Our discussion will include the following solutions:

Solution 1: Understanding cAdvisor Metrics and Reporting
Solution 2: Verifying Memory Limits and Requests in Kubernetes
Solution 3: Inspecting Container Memory Usage with kubectl
Solution 4: Analyzing Memory Overhead from System Daemons
Solution 5: Adjusting Memory Allocation in Docker and Kubernetes
Solution 6: Using Prometheus for Accurate Memory Monitoring

By looking at these solutions, we will learn how to manage memory usage in our Kubernetes environment. If we have seen related issues, like our Kubernetes pods crashing or need help with setting memory limits, the tips we talk about here will help us. Let’s begin to solve the mystery of container memory usage in cAdvisor metrics!

Solution 1 - Understanding cAdvisor Metrics and Reporting

To solve the problem of seeing double memory usage in cAdvisor metrics, we need to understand how cAdvisor shows memory usage. cAdvisor collects data about containers and shares this through its web interface or Prometheus. Here is how we can read these metrics correctly:

Memory Usage Metrics:
- cAdvisor gives us several memory metrics:
  - Active Memory: This is the memory that the container uses right now.
  - Inactive Memory: This is memory that is not in use but is still counted.
  - Cached Memory: This is memory used for caching. We can take it back if we need to.
Memory Reporting:
- The memory usage we see could be the total of active and inactive memory. This makes it look like the usage is doubled. For example, if a container uses 200MB of active memory and another 200MB of inactive memory, cAdvisor will show 400MB total memory usage.
Understanding the Metrics:
- To check the reported memory usage, we can go to cAdvisor’s metrics link:
```
http://<CADVISOR_IP>:8080/metrics
```
- We should look for lines that start with container_memory_usage_bytes. This will show the memory metrics for each container.
Key Metrics to Monitor:
- container_memory_working_set_bytes: This tells us how much memory the container is using, not counting cache and buffers.
- container_memory_rss: This shows the part of memory used by a process that is in RAM.
Using Prometheus for Visualization:
- If we use Prometheus to get metrics from cAdvisor, we can write queries to visualize memory usage well. For example:
```
sum(container_memory_usage_bytes{image!="",container_name!="POD"}) by (pod_name)
```
- This query adds up the memory usage of all containers in a pod. This can help us understand the metrics better.
Common Misinterpretations:
- Many users misunderstand the sum of active and inactive memory as real usage. We must know the difference between active usage and the total memory shown by cAdvisor.

By understanding cAdvisor’s metrics and how it shows memory usage, we can find out why container memory usage looks doubled and take the right steps. If we want to learn more about managing Kubernetes resources, we can read this article on how to set Kubernetes resource limits.

Solution 2 - Verifying Memory Limits and Requests in Kubernetes

To understand why cAdvisor shows container memory usage as doubled, we need to check the memory limits and requests for our Kubernetes Pods. This problem often happens when memory is not set right. It can cause cAdvisor to show more memory usage than it should.

Checking Memory Requests and Limits

Inspect the Pod Configuration: We can use kubectl to see the memory requests and limits for our Pods. We do this by running:
```
kubectl get pod <pod-name> -n <namespace> -o=jsonpath='{.spec.containers[*].resources}'
```
This command gives us the resource requests and limits for all containers in the Pod we selected.
Example Output:
```
{
  "requests": {
    "memory": "512Mi"
  },
  "limits": {
    "memory": "1Gi"
  }
}
```
In this case, the Pod asks for 512Mi of memory and has a limit of 1Gi. If we do not set the limits right, the container can use more memory than we expect. This causes cAdvisor to report higher usage.
Verifying Configuration in YAML: We can also look at the memory limits and requests in the Pod’s YAML file. We can get the YAML by using this command:
```
kubectl get pod <pod-name> -n <namespace> -o yaml
```
Look for the resources section under each container:
```
resources:
  requests:
    memory: "512Mi"
  limits:
    memory: "1Gi"
```

Adjusting Requests and Limits: If we see the memory limits are not set or are too high, we can change the Pod definition. Here is an example of how to set the requests and limits in a Pod YAML file:

apiVersion: v1
kind: Pod
metadata:
  name: example-pod
  namespace: default
spec:
  containers:
    - name: example-container
      image: example-image
      resources:
        requests:
          memory: "512Mi"
        limits:
          memory: "1Gi"

We apply the changes using:

kubectl apply -f <your-pod-definition>.yaml

Monitoring Changes: After we change the memory limits and requests, we should watch the container memory usage again with cAdvisor. This helps us see if the memory usage is now more in line with what we expect.

By checking and changing memory requests and limits in Kubernetes, we can fix issues with high memory usage metrics shown by cAdvisor. This step is important for keeping our resources used well and improving performance in our Kubernetes setup. For more tips on managing Pods, check this guide on managing Kubernetes Pods.

Solution 3 - Inspecting Container Memory Usage with kubectl

If we see that container memory usage is doubled in cAdvisor metrics, we can use kubectl to check the memory of our containers. This way, we can see how much memory each container is really using. This helps us find the differences between cAdvisor reports and the real usage.

Check Pod Resource Metrics: We can run this command to see the memory usage of our pods:
```
kubectl top pods --namespace=<your-namespace>
```
Change <your-namespace> to the correct namespace where our pods are running. This command shows CPU and memory usage for each pod in that namespace.
Describe the Pod: If we want more details about a specific pod, we can describe it:
```
kubectl describe pod <pod-name> --namespace=<your-namespace>
```
This command gives us details about the memory limits and requests for the container. This can help us understand the differences in memory usage reports.
Inspect Container Logs: If we have memory usage issues, looking at the logs can help. We can use this command to get logs from a specific container in a pod:
```
kubectl logs <pod-name> -c <container-name> --namespace=<your-namespace>
```
Use JSONPath for Specific Metrics: If we want to get specific memory usage metrics, we can use JSONPath with kubectl. For example, to find the memory usage of a container in a pod:
```
kubectl get pod <pod-name> --namespace=<your-namespace> -o=jsonpath='{.status.containerStatuses[*].usage.memory}'
```
Monitor Resource Consumption Over Time: For ongoing checks, we can connect kubectl with a tool like Prometheus. We can set up Prometheus to collect metrics from our containers. This helps us see memory usage trends over time. It is useful for diagnosing memory allocation problems.

By using kubectl to check container memory usage directly, we can compare cAdvisor metrics with real usage. This helps us understand why memory usage looks doubled. It also lets us see if the memory limits and requests in our Kubernetes settings are correct and working well.

For more tips on managing memory and fixing Kubernetes issues, we can look at this guide on Kubernetes pod crashes.

Solution 4 - Analyzing Memory Overhead from System Daemons

When we see doubled memory usage in cAdvisor metrics, we need to think about how system daemons affect container memory. These daemons run on the host. They can add a lot to the memory numbers we see in cAdvisor. This can make it hard to know the real memory usage of containers.

Steps to Analyze Memory Overhead from System Daemons

Identify Running System Daemons: First, we need to list all the system daemons running on our Kubernetes nodes. We can use this command on our node to see the processes:
```
ps aux | grep -E 'kube|docker|containerd|systemd'
```
We should look for processes related to Kubernetes components like kubelet and kube-proxy. We also check container runtimes like Docker or containerd.
Check Memory Usage of System Daemons: Next, we can use the top or htop command to see how much memory these processes use in real-time. If we want more details, we can use this command:
```
sudo pmap -x <PID>
```
We need to replace <PID> with the process ID of the daemon we want to check. This will show us how much memory each daemon is using.
Review cAdvisor Metrics: Now, we should open the cAdvisor UI to look at memory metrics for our containers. We need to pay attention to the “RSS” (Resident Set Size) and “Cache” metrics. These metrics help us see how much memory is from the container and how much is from system daemons.
Cross-Reference with Kubernetes Metrics: We can use kubectl to get metrics about our pods and nodes. This command will give us a summary of memory usage:
```
kubectl top pods --all-namespaces
```
We should compare this output with what cAdvisor shows. This will help us check if the memory usage matches the expected limits for our containers.

Adjust Resource Allocations if Necessary: If we find that system daemons are using too much memory, we might need to change the resource requests and limits in our container settings. For example, we can set resource limits in our deployment config like this:

apiVersion: apps/v1
kind: Deployment
metadata:
  name: my-app
spec:
  replicas: 3
  selector:
    matchLabels:
      app: my-app
  template:
    metadata:
      labels:
        app: my-app
    spec:
      containers:
        - name: my-container
          image: my-image
          resources:
            requests:
              memory: "512Mi"
              cpu: "500m"
            limits:
              memory: "1Gi"
              cpu: "1"

By checking the memory overhead from system daemons, we can understand better how memory is allocated for our containers. This helps us make our Kubernetes environment work better. If we have problems with pod stability or want to learn more about memory management, we can look at this guide.

Solution 5 - Adjusting Memory Allocation in Docker and Kubernetes

To fix the problem of doubled memory use shown by cAdvisor in Kubernetes, we need to change memory allocation settings in Docker and Kubernetes. Setting memory limits and requests right will help our containers not use more resources than they need.

Adjusting Memory Allocation in Docker

When we run Docker containers, we can set memory limits in the docker run command. This stops containers from using too much memory, which can make usage numbers look high.

Here is an example of how to set memory limits:

docker run -m 512m --memory-swap 1g my-container

In this command:

-m 512m sets the memory limit to 512 MB.
--memory-swap 1g lets the container use a swap space of up to 1 GB.

For Docker Compose, we can set memory limits in the docker-compose.yml file:

version: "3.7"
services:
  my-service:
    image: my-container
    deploy:
      resources:
        limits:
          memory: 512M
        reservations:
          memory: 256M

Configuring Memory Requests and Limits in Kubernetes

In Kubernetes, it is important to define memory requests and limits. This helps us manage resources well. This way, we avoid over-using memory and make sure our pods get the right amount of memory.

Here is an example of a pod specification in Kubernetes with memory requests and limits:

apiVersion: v1
kind: Pod
metadata:
  name: my-pod
spec:
  containers:
    - name: my-container
      image: my-image
      resources:
        requests:
          memory: "256Mi"
        limits:
          memory: "512Mi"

In this setup:

requests.memory shows the memory that the container will definitely get (256 MiB).
limits.memory shows the most memory that the container can use (512 MiB).

Monitoring and Adjusting

After we change memory allocation, we should watch the real memory use of our containers. We can use commands like kubectl top to see how resources are used:

kubectl top pod my-pod

This command gives us the current memory and CPU use for the pod we want. If we see that memory use is still more than we thought, we should look again at how our application uses memory and change the limits if needed.

For better monitoring and to collect metrics in Kubernetes, we can add Prometheus to our setup. It gives us detailed info about memory use and performance.

By changing memory allocation in Docker and Kubernetes, we can fix the problem of high memory use in cAdvisor metrics. This will help us manage resources better and improve application performance. For more information, check out this article on how to set multiple commands in Docker.

Solution 6 - Using Prometheus for Accurate Memory Monitoring

To fix the problem of doubled memory use in cAdvisor metrics, we can use Prometheus for monitoring. This tool gives us a clear and detailed view. Prometheus is an open-source tool for monitoring and alerting. Many people use it in Kubernetes. With Prometheus, we can collect detailed metrics about how containers use memory. This helps us find issues and see how we use resources.

Setting Up Prometheus for Kubernetes

Install Prometheus: We can use the Prometheus Operator to make it easier to set up in Kubernetes. We can install it with Helm:

helm repo add prometheus-community https://prometheus-community.github.io/helm-charts
helm repo update
helm install prometheus prometheus-community/kube-prometheus-stack

Configure Prometheus: We must make sure Prometheus can get metrics from cAdvisor. The default setup usually works, but we can change it in the values.yaml file:
```
prometheus:
  prometheusSpec:
    serviceMonitorSelector:
      matchLabels:
        app: kube-prometheus
```
Access Prometheus UI: To see the metrics Prometheus collects, we can port-forward the Prometheus service:
```
kubectl port-forward svc/prometheus-operated 9090:9090 -n monitoring
```
Then, we can visit the Prometheus UI at http://localhost:9090.

Querying Container Memory Usage

We can use Prometheus queries to get memory metrics. Some important metrics are:

container_memory_usage_bytes: This shows how much memory the container is using right now.

We can run this query to check the memory usage for all containers:

sum(container_memory_usage_bytes{job="kubelet", metrics_path="/metrics/cadvisor"}) by (container_name, namespace)

Creating Alerts for Memory Usage

We should set alerts in Prometheus. This will tell us when memory usage goes over a certain limit. This helps us keep track of things:

groups:
  - name: memory-alerts
    rules:
      - alert: HighMemoryUsage
        expr: sum(container_memory_usage_bytes{job="kubelet", metrics_path="/metrics/cadvisor"}) / sum(kube_pod_container_resource_requests_memory_bytes) > 0.9
        for: 5m
        labels:
          severity: warning
        annotations:
          summary: "High memory usage detected"
          description: "Container memory usage is above 90% for more than 5 minutes."

Integrating with Grafana

To see the data that Prometheus collects, we can use Grafana:

Install Grafana:
```
helm install grafana grafana/grafana
```
Access Grafana: We need to port-forward the Grafana service:
```
kubectl port-forward svc/grafana 3000:80
```
Now, we can go to Grafana at http://localhost:3000 and log in with default info (admin/admin).
Add Prometheus Data Source: In Grafana, we go to Configuration > Data Sources, and we add Prometheus as a new data source with the URL http://prometheus-operated:9090.
Create Dashboards: We can use the container memory metrics to make dashboards. This helps us see memory usage trends and spot any problems.

By using Prometheus for memory monitoring, we can see how containers use memory. This helps us fix the doubled memory use in cAdvisor metrics. We can also make sure our Kubernetes clusters run well.

For more information on related Kubernetes monitoring topics, look at this article on Kubernetes service external IP or this guide on memory limits and requests.

Conclusion

In this article, we looked at why cAdvisor shows doubled memory usage in Kubernetes. We gave some easy solutions. These include understanding cAdvisor metrics. Also, we talked about checking memory limits and changing memory allocation.

By using these tips, we can make our container memory usage better. This will help our application run smoother. If you want to know more, we suggest reading about how to pull environment variables and how to set up multiple commands in Kubernetes.

Best Online Tutorials

Search This Blog